Jury reports that Steon's Orbo does not produce free energy

By Mark Frauenfelder at 2:19 PM June 23, 2009

The Orbo doesn't work, reports a jury of scientists and engineers selected by perpetual motion company Steorn to analyze its technology.

Twenty-two independent scientists and engineers were selected by Steorn to form this jury. It has for the past two years examined evidence presented by the company. The unanimous verdict of the Jury is that Steorn's attempts to demonstrate the claim have not shown the production of energy. The jury is therefore ceasing work.
The blogger who runs a blog about Steorn says:
As I see it there have always been three possibilities for Steorn: either they truly have free energy technology, or they're a fraud, or they're mistaken and delusional. Today's development can be taken as weighty evidence that they are, in fact, mistaken and delusional.
Steorn Jury Announcement

15 Comments Add a comment

Takuan #1 14:28 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

drop another ziploc of frogs in the hail cannon.

lumpi #2 14:38 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

What amazes me is that the verdict was "delusional" rather than "fraud". How sad is that?

aplusbi #3 14:51 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

In other news, water is wet and fire is hot.

Daemon #4 15:08 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

They could be mistaken and NOT delusional.

Anon #5 16:48 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

Speaking of perpetual motion, I have seen cell phones that now collect all freqs of radio waves and converts them into energy charging your batt.
Sounds good to me, now we just need to build one to power houses and other large equip.

Snig #6 19:08 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

They could have different departments that collaborate. Fraud Division, the Mistaken unit which has under it's jurisdiction the Department of Delusion. As suggested, everyone in Delusion is part of the Mistaken, but some in Mistaken are not under Delusion.

agger #7 21:45 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

Steorn: 0 - first law of thermodynamics: 1

Dillenger69 #8 23:37 on Tue, Jun.23 Reply

It looks like Homer Simpson's household rule still stands.

Pseudothink #9 00:41 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

Given the amount of venture capital that some quasi-credible cold fusion "pioneers" seem to generate, it seems like a potentially viable business model to me. The Cold Fusion Con is just the physicist/scientist/engineer's version of cashing in on their name. Just like what happens when celebrities give up and start endorsing timeshares, instructional tapes, or exercise products.

HotPepperMan #10 01:26 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

Aah, if only one could capture the energy generated by people's outpouring of negativity. How the masses love others to fail...

Pseudothink #11 02:13 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

Where does the energy content of the self-righteous factor in? :P

Certhas #12 03:30 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

"The law that entropy always increases holds, I think, the supreme position among the laws of Nature. If someone points out to you that your pet theory of the universe is in disagreement with Maxwell's equations — then so much the worse for Maxwell's equations. If it is found to be contradicted by observation — well, these experimentalists do bungle things sometimes. But if your theory is found to be against the second law of thermodynamics I can give you no hope; there is nothing for it but to collapse in deepest humiliation." — Sir Arthur Stanley Eddington

Anon #13 05:11 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

What gets me is the comments on the article basically saying "Your jury made these conclusions based on outdated data. Your results are wrong!" As though something has changed to make this stuff actually work.

Anon #14 08:54 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

There is more to this story. It took 2 years for them to reach a conclusion. It only takes 2 seconds to say "Laws of Thermodynamics". While from a science and engineering perspective, free energy is impossible; from an economic perspective, free energy machines, in the form of waterwheels, have existed for thousands of years. If it took 2 whole years for a group of smart people to figure this thing out, than maybe it is not so cut and dry as thermodynamics

lumpi #15 11:05 on Wed, Jun.24 Reply

Yep, the waterhweel argument is actually a good one, IMO. The sun, wind, water... who says there isn't another form of "wasted" energy flying around.

It would be much more reasonable to say that you harvest an exotic but existing form of energy than saying you create it out of nothing in a sterile, motionless environment. That's what Orbo promised, and it will never work.

Add a comment

Anonymous

Speech is free, but Boing Boing is moderated. Comments may be deleted or disemvoweled. Anonymous comments are not automatically published. Please don't make racist, sexist or homophobic remarks or use associated offensive terms. Please don't talk politics in unrelated threads. Please don't cuss at or harass other commenters. Please don't post signatures, spam, astroturf or copypasta. Link to your website only on your profile page. Stay on topic. Read the full moderation policy. Thank you!

Features

Reviews Videos

More Features